Corpun file 24672 at www.corpun.com
Daily Mail, London, 6 July 1946
Court-martial sets great jungle-war problem
Had Wingate the right to flog?
By Murray Edwards
Daily Mail Reporter
The right of General Wingate of Burma to order any of his
Chindits to be flogged, shot, or turned loose in the jungle for
an offence that would endanger comrades' lives, was discussed in
a third-floor back attic in Curzon-street, Mayfair, yesterday.
And his right to break King's Regulations was challenged.
Major Phillip Herbert Graves-Morris, D.S.O., M.C., one of
Wingate's commanders, was facing a court-martial.
He was charged on two counts with ordering R.S.M. Hemmings to
flog two privates named Dexter and Smith, both of the Yorkshire
and Lancashire Regiment, for going to sleep while on sentry duty
200 miles behind the Jap lines.
Private Dexter, demobbed now, sat with his wife in a waiting room
throughout the four-hour hearing. He was not called.
His only comment afterwards was, "I'm not complaining."
The court allowed a plea of condonation subject to confirmation
by the convening body. If it is confirmed Major Graves-Morris
will be acquitted.
The attic in which the court sat used to be a rest room for
ATS girls. On its bare walls were pasted crude drawings of jungle
Waiting in the passage outside, to give evidence, were high
Chindit officers, including Brigadier W. Lentaigne, who took over
the command after Wingate was killed in 1944, and Brigadier
Ferguson, who had a monocle dropped for him in the jungle after
he had lost his own.
Major Graves-Morris pleaded "Not guilty in bar of
trial," to both charges, and Mr. Russell Vick, K.C., who
appeared for him, said this meant that even if the offences had
been committed they had been condoned by a senior officer after
Major Graves-Morris had reported the incidents to his Brigadier
and the Brigadier had simply said "O.K." as it was a
The flogging, Mr. Vick said, was carried out with a thin cane
after both Dexter and Smith had signed a document saying they
were willing to take such punishment in place of 25 days' field
punishment that had been awarded by Major Graves-Morris.
Because of the rigour of the campaign, which he described as
"hellish," no field punishment -- even if it could have
been carried out -- would equal the ordinary life of the
The whole matter had caused Major Graves-Morris considerable
anxiety and expense. At the time of the incidents he was a
lieut-colonel commanding 84 Column of the Chindits.
"The soldiers concerned," said Mr. Vick, "took
their punishment like sportsmen. It was more of a schoolmaster's
caning than the old 200 lashes."
Click to enlarge
Brigadier W.D.A. Lentaigne, who commanded a Chindit Brigade in
1943, and eventually took over from Wingate, said that he and
General Wingate often discussed discipline in long-range
"General Wingate told me, he said, "that in these
operations men frequently committed crimes under the stress of
the circumstances which would endanger the safety of the whole
column and the lives of other men."
Wingate was in favour of unorthodox punishment, including
corporal punishments, which were the only kind that could be
The brigadier listed the crimes for which, he said, Wingate
advocated such punishments. They were -- stealing rations,
quitting a post while on sentry duty; sleeping on sentry duty;
desertion. The first was regarded as the most serious crime of
Answering Lieut. Col. G.A. Whiteley, prosecuting, Brigadier
Lentaigne agreed that King's Regulations did not allow flogging,
and that if Parliament had been flaunted [sic], it was
because of the abnormal conditions.
He himself would definitely have authorised the flogging of a
soldier in the circumstances.
He did not hear of it at the time because their only means of
communication was by faulty wireless, and it would have been
wrong to take up precious wireless time with such an incident.
He could not visit all forward units because they were not always
able to cut an airstrip out of the jungle for his light plane to
land, and when the monsoons started even that was impossible.
Colonel J.B. Jeffries, in a grey demob suit, said he was in
Wingate's 1943 operations and later became second in command of a
brigade. Wingate told him that because of the nature of the
operations. ordinary punishments could not be carried out.
Detention, C.B., and stoppage of pay were meaningless in the
jungle, Wingate said, and as rigid discipline had to be
maintained at all times C.O.s would have to award punishments not
normally expected or allowed by existing Army regulations.
Colonel Jeffries said that, in his view, flogging was the only
suitable punishment in certain cases, and he told his officers
He and Brigadier Brodie heard about the flogging of Dexter and
Smith in 1944, but they took no action because it had their full
Major F.H.J. Wyman, of Streatham, spoke of attending a lecture
given by General Wingate at Bangalore, late in 1943.
General Wingate said that K.R.s and the Army Act could not be
applied, Major Wyman told the court, "but discipline must be
maintained at any cost."
Then, shaking his finger to aid his memory and stress his points,
Major Wyman quoted General Wingate as saying:
"You will apply a scale I have laid down because I am
satisfied it is the only way you can hope to bring your men out
For serious offences that are likely to result in the lives of
your men, you are empowered to flog them, turn them loose with
rations and ammunition and, in exceptional cases, shoot them.
"You will accept the responsibility under my orders, and
those are my orders."
Major Wyman added: "He made it clear that if a man
committed a certain offence he was to be turned loose with his
five days' rations strapped on his back, and his rifle and
ammunition, to fend for himself in the jungle."
Lieut.-Col. T. Brodie -- a brigadier at the time -- said he
remembered the accused telling him in 1944 that he had had to
have a man flogged. He was convinced that it was within the
accused's powers and so he took no action. If such a man had been
shot he would have condoned it.
Major P.H. Graves-Morris, wearing the ribbons of the D.S.O. and
M.C., gave his evidence sitting on a kitchen chair.
He said: "I had been informed at lectures that it might be
necessary to inflict corporal punishment. I discussed the matter
with Colonel Jeffries who had had previous experience, and I had
read instructions that had been circulated."
The case of Dexter was reported to him by Major Bruce after they
had .fought a serious engagement over the 3,500ft high Chin Hills
in a monsoon.
Dexter was awarded 28 days' field punishment for sleeping on
sentry duty, but he did not remember the case of Smith and had
not been able to trace the name in his battalion.
Dexter was given the option of 12 strokes with a cane and told
that he would not lose his 25 days' pay, and all record of the
incident would be destroyed; and he agreed, and put it in writing
after being told it was entirely up to him.
Cross-examined, Major Graves-Morris said he did not offer Dexter
the opportunity of a court-martial because there was no chance of
carrying it out.
Then Mr. Russell Vick submitted that if an offence had been
committed it had been condoned when the brigadier advisedly took
The court decision was announced after an adjournment of ten
Private Dexter said later, that he had travelled from his home in
Carlton-road, Nottingham, for the hearing.
It was a letter he wrote to his brother-in-law that started the
inquiry. His brother-in-law wrote to Mr. Beverley Baxter, M.P.
for Wood Green.
Since 1881 --
THE War Office said last night: "Flogging is illegal
under the Army Act of 1881, and a modification in 1923 forbade
field punishment, which previously permitted binding an offender
to a fixed object -- a field gun, for instance -- for a number of
"In the height of battle a man spreading alarm or acting in
a cowardly fashion might there and then be flogged or even shot
by an officer.
"But that clause would not apply in this court-martial.
"The findings in this case really mean that the
responsibility does not belong to the officer put on trial, but
Follow-up: 16 October 1946 - Punishment code in the Chindits
About this website
Search this site
Country files: Corporal punishment in the British Army
External links for military CP
Archive up to 1975: UK
Other months for armed forces CP in UK: