corpunWorld Corporal Punishment Research

ruler   :  Archive   :  2004   :  US Reformatories Apr 2004



Reformatory CP - April 2004

Corpun file 13301

Arizona Republic, Phoenix, 3 April 2004

Teen Reach founder fires back at state

By Michael Ferraresi
The Arizona Republic

"We're still in operation," Teen Reach founder Bobby Torres said during a church service Friday in Scottsdale.

Members of an evangelical Christian group rallied around their pastor Friday as he accused state officials of "abducting" eight adult church members and depriving them of their religious liberties.

Bobby Torres, a former gang member and founder of the Teen Reach program, also said he filed an appeal Friday to keep six drug and alcohol rehab facilities from being shut down.

"We're still in operation," Torres said Friday during a service at Teen Reach's church in the Scottsdale Airpark. "We're still taking children (as patients)."

State officials ordered Teen Reach's group homes to close after finding a child had been severely bruised in a "supervised spanking."

Teen Reach charges parents as much as $35,000 for six months of drug and alcohol rehabilitation in a faith-based, "cold-turkey" program that many parents regard as a last resort for their troubled teens.

On Friday, Torres accused state Child Protective Services workers of "abducting" eight adult Bible school students from a house on Thunderbird Road last month during the investigation into the spanking allegation.

He said eight adults, some as young as 18, were confronted by CPS workers during a Bible study at a Teen Reach house and were forced outside. In the process, he said, some were verbally and physically abused, and their faith was mocked.

Torres presented affidavits from all eight.

David Matthews, director of the Department of Economic Security licensing office, who ordered the homes shut down, said caseworkers did only what was necessary to investigate the abuse allegations against Teen Reach.

"These (Bible students) are people who simply refused to cooperate," Matthews said. "We had a list of children we were looking for. . . . I believe CPS, with the (Phoenix) police and with a court order, took the action necessary.

"Had (Teen Reach) cooperated, the adults would have never been removed, period."

Matthews said he ordered the homes shut down after CPS reported that four or more of the group's adults pinned a child to the ground, and another lay across the child's back, so a parent could administer a spanking.

"It has nothing to do with any belief system," Matthews said. "There is no agency in the state that is permitted to beat a child."

Torres said Friday that Teen Reach condones supervised spanking as a form of faith-based rehabilitation.

In addition to the group homes, Teen Reach has 15 other properties around the Valley that house graduates from the program, other ministers and students.

Those operations have not been affected.

More than 50 members of Teen Reach's evangelical community turned out to support Torres at the group's church at 7645 E. Evans Road in Scottsdale.

Parents, too, voiced their support.

Paul Rastello of Phoenix said his 12-year-old son was "transformed" after praying with Torres.

Rastello said Teen Reach's spanking methods taught him the "belief systems and the steps taken to nurture" his son, who had been placed in more than one rehabilitation program.

"You explain to your child what has happened, what the consequences are, you pray about it, and after the spanking is done, it's done," Rastello said. "We used to go out for dinner, go out for ice cream, do something different (after the spanking)."

Meanwhile, neighbors of two Teen Reach properties said the homes have caused disturbances for several years and should be shut down.

Bernard Anderson, who lives next to the Thunderbird Road property where the eight Bible students were confronted, said he and other neighbors worked with Phoenix to institute a parking ban next to what Teen Reach called "God's Favorite House."

"We couldn't get in and out of the driveway," Anderson said. "If we brought people over for Sunday dinner, they couldn't find any place to park."

Charlie Ferrell lives next to a Teen Reach property on East Sharon Drive that he claims is a commercial business illegally operating in a residential neighborhood.

Ferrell said he has photos of Teen Reach members unloading commercial printing equipment from a truck.

"It's a mess, no one would want to live across from it," Ferrell said. "There's 50 to 100 cars that drive over there every day."

Corpun file 13296 (KYTV online), Springfield, Missouri, 30 April 2004

Former students, prosecutors question methods of some 'tough love' schools

Some parents turn to these private schools to try to save their children

By Cara Connelly
KY3 News

Jordan Blair has vivid memories of the treatment he and other students received at Mountain Park Baptist Boarding School, a private reform school in Patterson, Mo., north of Poplar Bluff. He says beatings, sleep deprivation and isolation from the outside world were part of the curriculum.

"There were other kids getting slammed around, pushed around, real aggressive behavior," said Blair, 19. "I would sit there and cry myself to sleep at night knowing that I'm standing there, I'm watching this happen and not doing anything about it."

Blair's parents sent him to the school in 2001 at age 16 to keep him from having to go to an Arkansas juvenile facility. A judge in Crawford County, Ark., ruled Blair was a juvenile delinquent after convicting him of making a terroristic threat. The former student remembers severe consequences for misbehavior at Mountain Park, which is a mission of the Mountain Park Baptist Church.

"We have sleep deprivation," said Blair. "Bathroom privileges are extremely limited. You are watched. You have someone who is within what they call slapping distance."

Blair was only at the school for a few weeks before he was transferred to a sister school in Florida. He later escaped from that school.

Blair, who now lives in Alma, Ark., sued Mountain Park, its employees and its owners in federal court. He claimed staff members falsely imprisoned him. He also said the discipline violated his civil rights. A judge threw out most of the lawsuit but, earlier this month, a jury in Cape Girardeau ordered the school to pay Blair $20,000 because a staff member shoved him against a sink on his first day at the school. The school's attorney says he will appeal the verdict.

"In jail, you have certain guidelines and rules and everything," said Blair. "Well, when you go there, you don't know what those rules are. You have no idea. The state doesn't even know what those rules are."

Representatives of Mountain Park did not respond to a reporter's request for comments about Blair's charges.

This isn't an isolated case. Founders and staff members of other religious based schools in Missouri face criminal charges and civil lawsuits that contend their tough love goes too far.

Desperate parents often turn to private schools because they see them as their last chances to save kids who face problems at school, with the law, or with drugs and alcohol. These tough love schools promise to turn young lives around. Parents pay as much as $1,000 a month.

Missouri seems to attract these schools because the state doesn't regulate them. No specific laws protect their students. They're not even required to have health department inspections of their cafeterias.

A former staff member of Mountain Park started Thanks to Calvary Baptist Church & Boarding Academy near Waynesville. Now the Rev. Nathan Day faces four felony child abuse charges. Prosecutors believe Day beat Christopher Jansen. Missouri State Highway Patrol investigators also believe Day tied Jansen to the back of a lawn mower and an ATV and made him run behind them. Each time he fell, according to an investigator's report filed with the criminal charges, Rev. Day dragged him a few feet before stopping.

"I have a young man that's grievously injured, was in a catatonic coma for weeks and weeks and weeks and will need treatment the rest of his life," said Tyce Smith, Jansen's attorney.

The handbook of Thanks to Calvary makes no secret about using corporal punishment. Parents or guardians have to sign an Enrollment Agreement and initial certain sections to acknowledge they understand how children will be treated.

"A maximum of fifteen (15) swats of any kind ... may be administered in a 24-hour period," the Enrollment Agreement says.

Students can also be put in a "Bible Dormitory" and made to wear pajamas and flip-flops, where the lights stay on around the clock. There, students may be forced to sweep a dirt drive and dig a hole with a teaspoon.

In response to a reporter's telephone calls and letters to Thanks to Calvary, asking for a response to the charges and for a tour, the school's attorney answered with a letter.

"We believe the criminal charges are ridiculous," the attorney said. "We believe they are greatly exaggerating the supposed 'injuries' that this young man has received."

At least seven religious reform schools are in Missouri. Some moved here from other states.

"Parents need to understand, the state of Missouri needs to understand, what's actually going on," said Blair.

Former state Sen. Roseanne Bentley, R-Springfield, fought hard for regulation in the Legislature but failed to change Missouri's lack of oversight.

"There's no regulation at all, which is worrisome because the state's responsibility is to the most vulnerable people within the state," said Bentley.

One reform school opened its doors to a reporter and a photographer. Agape Boys Boarding Academy in Stockton, like the other schools, has strict rules and strong religious beliefs but its staff members don't use corporal punishment. A reporter observed misbehaving students doing jumping jacks and standing with their faces to a wall during a meal.

"We do push ups and work details. There are a lot of things we do. We used to do corporal discipline but we've gotten away from it," said director Jim Clemensen. "I believe it in. I think it's right but, as far as us here, we decided not to do it."

Agape's methods seem to be working. Students say the school has turned around their lives.

"If you look at my past and look at the stuff I was doing and look at my future, I might be a pastor and it's like, 'Wow!'" said Lane Gerry, a student at Agape.

Blair hopes his lawsuit will encourage other schools to change their policies.

"These people are going to be held accountable for what they do, not only by some 19-year-old kid but hopefully by the State of Missouri," he said.

Besides Bentley, other lawmakers from both parties have, at different times, proposed bills that would regulate these schools. A state senator from St. Louis has a bill pending this session but doesn't think it will get out of committee.

blob Follow-up: 28 May 2004 - Beleaguered teen reform school shuts down

blob THE ARCHIVE index  Main menu page

Copyright Colin Farrell 2004
Page created: June 2004